just wrote a scene that took on a life of its own, in a rather frightening way. It wasn’t supposed to be a happy scene; it features my heroine and a rather unsavory character who we meet in the first chapter of the book. In my brief sketch of the chapter, I’d labeled the scene “J. confronts T.”
The scene was supposed to be a little frightening. But it turned incredibly squicky, and it almost horrified me to write it. This is not at all the kind of thing I want to think about. I kept thinking that I shouldn’t go down that path–but the fact of the matter is, I think I do need to go there. I can’t pull my punches on this one, and if I just settled for a mere threat of physical violence here, I don’t think I’d be properly escalating the tension.
Frustratingly, the scene’s not very good yet, because it is so squicky that I’m shying away from writing it well. I have to fight myself not to dial down the language; it’s probably the hardest three pages I have had to write all book. This is not the kind of scene I signed up to write when I said I wanted to be a romance author. And yet it is exactly the scene that’s demanded here. When I made a decision to raise the stakes and punch up my heroine’s conflict, I think I knew in the back of my mind that this is what I was doing to myself. And to her. This is so far outside of my comfort zone.
Without further ado, one sentence from the hardest scene I’ve ever written:
“Jacob,” Thalia said quietly, “I am your sister, not your wife.”
So what about you? How far outside your comfort zone have you had to push yourself? And how do you make yourself get there?









May 18th, 2007 at 8:03 am
Like everything else in my life, I just keep butting my head up against it until something gives. Luckily I’m so hard headed it isn’t usually me that does the giving. As to what is outside my comfort zone - everything! Suzie is contantly outside my comfort zone, a lot of the revisions I’ve done on Zack are outside my comfort zone, the last rough draft… shudder. We aren’t going there.
Alice
May 18th, 2007 at 8:43 am
Well, indeed.
I’ll be looking forward (kinda) to reading that one! Decibel level sounds cranked.
May 18th, 2007 at 11:00 am
Hm. I wonder if I read that right…
May 18th, 2007 at 12:08 pm
I’m not good at writing outside of my comfort zone. Actually I just plain suck. However for my third book I will definitely have to push the envelope (at least for me).
May 18th, 2007 at 12:53 pm
I don’t know about the decibel level, Tessa. Right now, it’s just . . . hard to deal with.
This is not anything I’ve ever thought about, and it makes me wonder–if I shy from thinking about it, will readers not want to read it? It’s short–it’s the only scene of its kind in the book–but it is so freaking taboo I can’t even think about it.
Alice, good for you! Regularly pushing your boundaries is really excellent. And Bev–I’m sure you’ll rise to the challenge.
May 19th, 2007 at 8:01 am
I have no idea how it will work out in the commercial arena, CM, but I do know that my fic beta wrote one of the most powerful pieces I’ve ever read right smack dab on top of a huge taboo.
Editing it was hard, writing it nearly killed her, but in the end, what she’d written rang true. She agonized before deciding to send it out into the world, and eventually did. The controversy was frightening in its intensity.
And I think that’s the mark of whether your readers will or won’t accept what you’re doing. Think of what Anna C. did — it rang true, and people reacted to it in powerful (but not always positive) ways.
If anybody can pull something like this off, I am confident you are that person.
May 19th, 2007 at 12:40 pm
Did he lose his memory or something? What a line!
the scenes that I have a harder time with are the suspense parts. I never really thought I would be writing them. Not that I have a lot, but a few.
May 19th, 2007 at 4:25 pm
No. Jacob did not lose his memory.
As Chris says, it’s just a scene that trenches on extremely powerful taboos.